Tuesday, February 14, 2023

Open letter to Mr. Richard Branson of the Virgin Group on the best way forward for Cuba

Dear Mr. Richard Branson,

Read your blog, saw your Tweet, and believe that you are driven by good intentions to opine on Cuba, but as the German philosopher once said, "the devil is in the details." 

First, I found the two photos you posted of yourself touring Havana in 2017 with Eusebio Leal, the city historian to be ironic.

Photo: Richard Branson blog, Twitter 2023

Military control of economy expanded during Obama thaw 

Over a quarter of a century Mr. Leal through an extensive restoration effort transformed Old Havana into a "colonial jewel" and he was able to operate the City Historian's Office throughout this time, it became a hub of influence with budgetary freedom. This ended during Obama's detente. 

Andrea Rodriguez, the Associated Press correspondent in Cuba, in her September 8, 2016 article "Cuban military expands its economic empire under detente" found: "That independence is gone. Last month [August 2016], the Cuban military took over the business operations of Leal's City Historian's Office, absorbing them into a business empire that has grown dramatically since the declaration of detente between the U.S. and Cuba on Dec. 17, 2014."

The Obama thaw coincided with the Castro regime's military expanding its control over the Cuban economy. 

You state that the embargo has been "codified multiple times." My understanding is that it has been codified twice, and modified once.

When the embargo was codified into law, and trade opened

It was first codified in the 1992 Cuban Democracy Act, during the Bush Administration, that also opened up exports of food and medicine, as well as permitting family remittances, postal services, and telecommunications to and from Cuba.  

The second time was in 1996, following the February 24, 1996 shoot down of two civilian planes of the civil society group Brothers to the Rescue in international airspace on Raul Castro's orders in a premeditated act of state terrorism that killed four U.S based civilians. 

The Clinton administration had the following options: do nothing, apply sanctions, or a military strike. They opted for the second option and signed the Cuban Liberty and Democratic Solidarity Act of 1996. 

This transferred authority over U.S. policy toward Cuba from the Executive Branch to the Legislative. 

Congress loosened Cuba sanctions in the Trade Sanctions and Reform Act of 2000 (“TSRA”). This meant that cash and carry trade began between American companies and the Cuban dictatorship and its military conglomerate GAESA.

Mr. Obama's thaw with General Castro coincided with more repression, brain damaged diplomats


You mention in your blog that the Cuban government committed to bilateral talks: "to address issues like migration or mail service," but failed to mention the escalation in repression against dissidents during this "thaw" that began in 2009. 

Two months prior to the high point of the Obama detente, replacing a plaque that said "U.S. Interests Section" with one that said "Embassy of the United States of America" on July 20, 2015 a vicious attack was carried out to silence a former government official.

In a vicious machete attack on May 24, 2015, Sirley Ávila León lost her left hand, nearly lost her right upper arm, had her knees slashed, and was left with crippling injuries. She was denied adequate medical care, and doctors secretly advised her that she would need to leave Cuba if she wanted to recover. The regime had been embarrassed by a campaign she organized to keep a school open. She arrived in Miami on March 8, 2016, and with the help of the Cuban exile community, a team of medical professionals took care of her. By September of 2016, Sirley was able to return home to Cuba. She found her home occupied by strangers and went to her mother’s house. A short time later a camera was set up outside to spy on her. By mid-October 2016, Sirley was getting death threats from state security and feared for her life. She fled back to the United States a couple of weeks later and sought asylum.

You made mention that "both nations also agreed to reopen embassies in Washington and Havana," but left out that downgraded embassies, but fully staffed, called Interest Sections were established by Jimmy Carter and Fidel Castro on September 1, 1977. 

You also omitted the mysterious Havana Syndrome that began to harm both U.S. and Canadian diplomats in Nov 2016, and appears to have been a directed energy device. NBC News reported on this in December 2021. 

On February 20, 2022 the CBS News program Sixty Minutes reported on diplomat's children harmed by the Havana Syndrome. It was during Obama's opening the attacks began. U.S. diplomats over the past 39 years in Cuba were harassed, threatened, but not permanently harmed.

You cite your visit to Cuba during the Obama thaw as ground for your claim "that the Cuban people found something new that had been so elusive for decades: hope and opportunity." If that were true why did over 120,000 flee Cuba during the opening?

These Cubans fled because they knew President Obama would close the door on Cubans, and that the thaw would benefit the dictatorship and harm them.  Mr. Obama ended the Wet Foot - Dry Foot policy, and also ended a an asylum program for trafficked Cuban doctors on January 12, 2017. 

Would also recommend reading Hungarian-born political sociologist Paul Hollander's book Political Pilgrims: Western Intellectuals in Search of the Good Society and the section in which he catalogues the strategies and tactics totalitarian regimes use to control what one sees visiting their respective countries and what the unintended consequences are for its victims. 

Machete attacks, breaking bones, knife attacks since 2012
 

Trump sanctions targeted Cuban military

Obama-era openings benefited the Cuban military. Mr. Trump in 2017,  undid them through executive orders that forced Havana to open the economy to the non-military.  

On February 6, 2021 the Cuban government announced it would "allow small private businesses to operate in most fields, eliminating its limited list of activities, state-run media reported".  Why return to a policy that would reverse these changes further empower the Cuban military's control over the national economy, and not everyday Cubans?

Important not to be complicit in Cubans' suffering

We have not lost sight of the human cost and terrible despair caused by the isolation of the Cuban people or the fact that this was the policy of the Cuban dictatorship for decades. Even phone calls were discouraged, and punished. Families are still being divided by Havana in 2023.

Cuban nationals Omara Urquiola (left) and Anamely Ramos (Right) not allowed to return home.

Today, American Airlines and Southwest Airlines are complicit in carrying out Havana's orders to prevent Cuban nationals Anamely Ramos and Omara Urquiola, and others from returning home to Cuba, leaving them stateless persons, separated from their families.

Has your airline, Virgin Atlantic, also engaged in this practice, in order to do business with the Cuban government?

Thank you for speaking out on behalf of Cuba's political prisoners. You are right when you give the following description: "many of them young people who were detained for simply filming protests and never had due process in court." There are over 1,000 political prisoners with out including thousands more imprisoned for pre-crime. 

The New York Times reported on January 13, 2020 that documents obtained by a former senior judge in Cuba "showed that approximately 92 percent of those accused in the more than 32,000 cases that go to trial in Cuba every year are found guilty. Nearly 4,000 people every year are accused of being “antisocial” or “dangerous,” terms the Cuban government uses to jail people who pose a risk to the status quo, without having committed a crime."

 It is a complex, layered problem

We are agreed that this is complex, and layered problem, it is not only a Cuban problem, but it is not impossible to navigate. The question for you is what is the final goal? 

The Cuban government is clear about its goals. 

1. Continue to advance its anti-U.S. agenda on the world stage working closely with Russia, China, Iran, Syria, North Korea, Venezuela, and Nicaragua to create an authoritarian international order. 

2. Continue to empower regime elites in the private sector copying the Russian oligarch model. No rule of law, but rule by those connected to those in the center of power. Dissenters continue to be crushed.  

3. Continue to weaponize migration to leverage the United States while ignoring the human cost in lives lost. Havana has done this in 1965, 1980, 1994, 2014-16, and is doing it now because they perceive the current U.S. administration as weak, and malleable. 

Most everyone else 

1. Most Cubans want a democratic transition to a system based in the rule of law where entrepreneurs can flourish and human rights are respected, including property rights. 

2. They want to be left alone to pursue their own life goals, and live in freedom. They would like to do this in Cuba, but if that is not an option Cubans will continue to seek to do so elsewhere.  

This was what you heard in the shouts of freedom, and calls for an end to the dictatorship by tens of thousands of Cubans across the island in July of 2021. 

Finally, your concerns about Russia and China are mistaken. 

The Castro regime rushed to Moscow's and Beijing's side in 1959 while the United States had normal diplomatic and trade relations with Cuba. Havana's ideology is both anti-United States and anti-Western Democracy.  

Havana's relations with Beijing were not determined by relations with the United States, but the Sino-Soviet split. Relations were restored in the late 1980s with Cuba one of the few countries that supported the Tiananmen Square massacre in 1989. 30/

Relations with Moscow cooled during the Gorbachev-Yeltsin era. Soviet publications with articles on Glasnost and Perestroika were banned. Members of the Cuban military "contaminated" by reformist ideas were purged, and some were executed. Relations with Russia warmed again with Putin in 2000, and grown closer as he has become more authoritarian.  

One last observation and two questions Mr. Branson. I remember the humanitarian concert you organized for Venezuelan refugees in 2019, and commend you for it. 

How do you feel about the role the Cuban dictatorship has played in propping up Maduro in Venezuela?

Cuban forces in Venezuela, described as an "occupation force" by OAS Secretary General Luis Almagro, are training Venezuelans in torture techniques and supervising torture sessions. 

Is providing more resources to the Castro regime to carry out its overseas goals of destroying democracies something that you want to facilitate?

Thank you Mr. Branson for your time and interest in the well-being of the Cuban people. 

From one troublemaker to another.

Cordially,

John Suarez

Saturday, February 11, 2023

Iranians in Miami, and around the world hold freedom rallies and call for Mullahs to be sanctioned. Meanwhile, Biden Administration lifts sanctions on Iran and Russia.

“It’s not important if you are monarchist, republican or religious, raise your hands if you are a victim of the Islamic Republic and unite.” - Masih Alinejad, February 11, 2023

Iranians in Miami hold a freedom rally for Iran, and for Mullahs to be sanctioned.

On February 11, 2023, Iranians around the world protested the 44th anniversary of the Islamic Regime taking power in Iran. In the United States, Iranian activists circulated petitions for the U.S. Congress to pass the Mahsa Act that would impose sanctions on the Iranian regime, and the Mullahs that run it.

Less than 24 hours earlier, on February 10, 2023, the Biden administration informed Congress that it was waiving nonproliferation sanctions on Iran so that Rosatom - Russia’s State Nuclear Energy Corporation - could profit without being subject U.S. sanctions.

The waivers roll back the Trump Administration’s sanctions on the Islamic Republic and allow Iran to cooperate with Russia at Iranian nuclear enrichment facilities.  This will speed up Iran's ability to develop nuclear weapons.

This is madness.

Russia dramatically escalated its invasion of Ukraine on February 22, 2022 and a bloody war has raged on the European continent over the past year with hundreds of thousands dead.  The Biden Administration failed to heed calls to preemptively sanction Russia before Putin widened the war, but imposed them afterwards.

The Islamic Republic of Iran continues to sponsor terrorism, and since nationwide protests erupted in Iran on September 17, 2022 over over 500 nonviolent protesters were killed, and over 19,700 arrested.

Iranian terrorism has also reached the U.S. mainland.

Iranian journalist Masih Alinejad was targeted by the Iranian Intelligence Services in a plot to kidnap her for rendition to Iran, revealed the FBI on July 13, 2021. A little over a year later on July 31, 2022 Khalid Mehdiyev, age 23, was found outside her home with an AK-47, a high-capacity magazine and more than $1,000 in cash. Mehdiyev is from Azerbaijan, and according to Jason Brodsky at the United Against Nuclear Iran nonprofit the dictatorship in Iran has been known to contract "Azeri hitmen to target Israelis in Cyprus."  

In the United States on August 12, 2022 novelist Salman Rushdie was repeatedly stabbed, and nearly died. In 1989,  Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini issued a fatwa calling for Rushdie's murder and set a $3 million bounty.  Iranian state media celebrated the 2022 attack. Friends of free speech organized readings of Salman Rushdie's work around the world in protest.

 

On an equally ominous front the Iranian Mullahs' foreign minister last week conducted a tour of Latin American dictatorships beginning with Nicaragua, where Daniel Ortega openly defended Tehran's right to have nuclear weapons, followed by a visit to Venezuela to meet with dictator Nicolas Maduro, and concluded the tour of despots visiting Miguel Diaz-Canel in Cuba. 

Both Havana and Caracas were on the UN Human Rights Council last year, and sought to cover up the Islamic Regime of Iran's gross and systematic human rights violations in key votes.  Venezuela ran for re-election to the Council, but was voted off.  There is a petition underway to remove Cuba from the UN Human Rights Council, and here is where you can sign it.

Now is not the time to lift sanctions on Russia or Iran, and their respective allies, but to tighten them in response to their illegal actions.  The Iranian opposition is united, and through six months of sustained nationwide protests with hundreds dead, and thousands jailed the Iranian people have demonstrated their rejection of the Islamist regime in Iran. 

Why is the Biden Administration lifting sanctions that will benefit both Russia, and Iran in their nuclear programs?

Sunday, February 5, 2023

Iranian Mullahs foreign minister visits the Islamic dictatorship's allies in the Americas: Diaz-Canel in Cuba, Maduro in Venezuela, and Ortega in Nicaragua

“Those who attempt to level, never equalize." ... "The levelers, therefore, only change and pervert the natural order of things; ” -  Edmund Burke, Reflections on the Revolution in France (1790)

The foreign minister of the Iranian Mullahs Hossein Amir-Abdollahian has been visiting the Islamist regime's allies in the region: Daniel Ortega in Nicaragua, Nicolas Maduro in Venezuela, and today arrived in Cuba "to confer with Cuban officials on issues of mutual interest."

Foreign Minister Amir-Abdollahian meets President Diaz-Canel

He met with Raul Castro's hand-picked president, Miguel Diaz-Canel, this afternoon.

Both Iran and Cuba are on the U.S. State Department's list of state sponsors of terrorism. Havana has played a key role in training torturers and soldiers to consolidate the dictatorships in both Nicaragua and Venezuela.

Foreign Minister Amir-Abdollahian meets President Nicolas Maduro

Havana's relationship with Tehran commenced in 1979, and both share a visceral anti-Americanism that unites their different revolutionary ideologies of Communism and Islamism.

All these regimes carried out revolutions promising equality, but delivered oppression, corruption, and a new ruling class over a poorer populace.

Foreign Minister Amir-Abdollahian meets President Daniel Ortega

This is a revolutionary subset of what Anne Applebaum calls "Autocracy Inc" that "unlike military or political alliances from other times and places, the members of this group don’t operate like a bloc, but rather like an agglomeration of companies."

Saturday, February 4, 2023

Observing the 110th anniversary of the birth of Rosa Parks

"I have learned over the years that when one's mind is made up, this diminishes fear; knowing what must be done does away with fear." - Rosa Parks

Rosa Parks: Civil rights icon

Rosa Parks was born one hundred and ten years ago today, February 4, 1913 in Tuskegee, Alabama. Four decades later, she would engage in a moment that would transform the United States of America through nonviolent action. Before the 1960 lunch counter sit-ins in Greensboro, North Carolina and the Reverend Martin Luther King Jr. there was Rosa Parks. 

On December 1, 1955, while sitting in the back of the bus [the area reserved for African Americans during segregation], the "white" section was filled to capacity with a white man standing, and the bus driver told Rosa Parks to stand up and give him her seat.

Rosa Parks refused and she was arrested, finger printed, photographed, jailed and fined $14 dollars for refusing to give up her seat. This action would lead to the Montgomery bus boycott that would inspire people of good will to action. Civil rights pioneer Rev. James Lawson on June 20, 2010 described what it was like to learn of the boycott:
"December 6, 1955 that was the date when many people in the world learned of the beginning of the Montgomery bus boycott in Montgomery, Alabama; a very simple stroke it was not initially called a non-violent movement. But Rosa Parks, Ed Nixon, Mary Jo Robinson, Martin King, Ralph Abernathy, and a host of other people who engaged that first effort sent a wave of hope around the world."

Rosa Parks would go on to live a long and productive life and passed away on October 24, 2005 at the age of 92. She was laid in state in the U.S. Capitol Rotunda. Rosa Parks was the first woman and second non-government official to be honored in such a manner.

Today, a hundred and ten years after Rosa Parks was born, women in Cuba inspired by her example have organized a movement, Rosa Parks Women's Civil Rights Movement , named after the civil rights pioneer and are engaged in marches and demonstrations in defense of human rights in Cuba. Much has been achieved since 1955 but challenges still remain and for Cuban women the battle for basic human rights continues.

Protests for a Free Iran continue, while the Mullahs respond with brutal repression: a call for solidarity

#WomenLifeFreedom

Nationwide protests in Iran following the killing of Mahsa Amini on September 16, 2022 have continued to the present day. The Iranian regime continues to respond with extreme brutality. 527 protesters have been killed, and over 19,000 arrested. 

Protests for freedom in Iran continue to take place around the world. A March for Iran will take place in Washington DC on Saturday, February 4th at 2:00pm at Freedom Plaza.

Next week, on February 11th, Iranians will hold a Freedom Rally at the Torch of Friendship in Miami, FL.

Please continue to follow Masih Alinejad @AlinejadMasih on Twitter and amplify her voice, and that of other Iranian women such as:  Nazanin Nour @NazaninNour, Roya Hakakian @RoyaTheWriter, Nazanin Boniadi @NazaninBoniadi, Nazenin Ansari @NazeninA, Nazanin Afshin-Jam MacKay @NazaninAJ, and Mariam Memarsadeghi @memarsadeghi.

These Iranian women are connected to what is happening in their homeland, they are providing up to date information on what is going on in Iran, campaigning for international solidarity from governments, organizations, people of good will and they are making history. 

Freedom House, a human rights organization founded in the United States in 1941, is circulating a petition calling for solidarity with Iran.

Martyred Cuban opposition leader Oswaldo Payá Sardiñas on December 17, 2002 in an address to the European Parliament explained the importance of prioritizing human rights and solidarity in the age of globalization. 

"The cause of human rights is a single cause, just as the people of the world are a single people. The talk today is of globalization, but we must state that unless there is global solidarity, not only human rights but also the right to remain human will be jeopardized. If there is no solidarity between people we will be unable to preserve a fair world in which it is possible to continue living as human beings. I therefore humbly believe that rather than new models, both for societies and for relations between countries, what we need is a new spirit. 

 This new spirit, which should find expression in solidarity, cooperation, and justice in the relations between countries, will not impede development, because if policies and models are made secondary to personal realization and the establishment of justice and democracy, and if policies are humanized, we will bridge the gulfs that divide peoples and will become a true human family."

The time for solidarity continues. The world is watching. The Iranian people are not alone. We are with you both in spirit and on the streets.