“Those who falsify history do not protect the freedom of a nation but, rather, constitute a threat to it.” – Vaclav Havel, The Salzburg Festival, July 26, 1990
The situation in Mexico
demands concrete attention and actions
in the hopes that a resolution can quickly be reached such as:
- Over social media there are numerous opportunities to demonstrate one's solidarity using hash tags such as: and #GlobalActionForAyotzinapa.
- In Miami on November 20, 2014 at 5pm in the Mexican Consulate in downtown (1399 SW 1st Avenue Miami, FL 33130) join with Mexican activists in a
nonviolent protest denouncing the crime while demanding justice and the
return of the 43 missing students to their loved ones. Please dress in black Protests also planned in Santa Ana, CA; Dallas, TX and elsewhere.
- Signing an online letter from Amnesty International
calling on the Mexican government to bring all responsible to justice,
acknowledge that this is not an isolated case, and for the government to
uphold 2012 commitment to eradicate torture and ill treatment of all
detainees.
- Writing opeds, letters to the editor, spreading the word over social
media on the internet in order that others may take concrete action on
behalf of these 43 students.
Meanwhile efforts by political partisans to take advantage of the situation to advance a particular agenda needs to be quashed while truth and justice serve as a guide to action on behalf of the 43. For example,
Venezuelan Analysis republished an article of Tamara Pearson of the Venezuela and Cuban sponsored television network
TELESUR titled
43 Lives, 2 Countries slandering the victims of the Maduro government killed during anti-government protests in 2014 while at the same time failing to mention that in the case of the
43 disappeared students in Mexico the government officials identified as having colluded with a drug gang in taking the students are members of a left wing political party with ties to both Venezuela and Cuba.
Both Mexico and
Venezuela are in the grips of waves of violence that have claimed tens of thousands of lives. Mexico with a population of 122.3 million according to the preliminary numbers published by the National Statistics Institute, (Inegi) had 22,732
homicides in 2013, equivalent to
22 per 100,000 inhabitants. Meanwhile, Venezuela with a population of 30.41 million
according to the Venezuelan Observatory on Violence, estimates that 24,000 people were murdered in 2013, according to the
United Nations and the
World Bank the number per capita is
54 per 100,000 inhabitants and is considered the second most likely place to be murdered on the planet with
Honduras in first place. The bottom line on murder rates is that you are 2.5 times more likely to be murdered in Venezuela than in Mexico.
 |
| Some of the Venezuelan youth shot in the head in 2014 during protests |
However, the questions surrounding the
43 Venezuelans and
43 Mexicans murdered in a political context in 2014 resonate in both countries and raise fundamental questions of governance.
The mayor of Iguala, José Luis Abarca, and his wife Maria de los Angeles Pineda are
suspected of ordering the disappearance of 43 students which
took place on September 26, 2014 and colluding with a drug gang called
Guerreros Unidos (United Warriors) who allegedly
murdered the students. The governor of Guerrero state, Angel Aguirre has
taken a leave of absence
due to growing criticism over his role in the affair. Both the mayor
and governor are members of the Party of the Democratic Revolution
(PRD). Leaked
diplomatic cables of the U.S. embassy
in Mexico indicate that the Mexican president Calderon believed that
Hugo Chavez's government had secretly funded the PRD candidate's
election in 2006. The
PRD also has
good relations with the
Cuban dictatorship.
Since February 12, 2014 forty three Venezuelans have been killed during protests against rising insecurity and vanishing rights in their country. Over 5,000 have been injured and
3,000 arbitrarily detained. Among them is the opposition leader Leopoldo Lopez who advocated for nonviolent protests and remains arbitrarily detained
despite the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention on August 26, 2014 calling for his immediate release.The students shot and killed in the demonstrations by government soldiers and paramilitaries that work with the Maduro government.
The pattern of conduct and impunity that took place in Venezuela and Iguala with their respective
43 students is troublingly similar. A government official unhappy with student protesters orders troops to put down their demonstration and uses non-government para-military groups as shock troops to terrorize nonviolent students. This includes
unarmed Venezuelan students shot and killed at point blank range. The difference between what happened in Mexico and in Venezuela is that in the Mexican case it is a local official while in the Venezuelan case national officials are involved.
What happened in Venezuela?
The series of events that sparked the student demonstrations in Venezuela began in Táchira on February 4, 2014 when a student at the University of Los Andes in the Botanical Garden of the University was the victim of an attempted rape. Students protested that "insecurity had taken over the campus." The protest was repressed and a number of students arrested and physically mistreated by the authorities. The news of the abuse by government officials sparked additional protests.
The February 10th open letter tweeted
by student leader Juan Requesens, who has more than 528,000 followers
the message is one that is open to dialogue with the government on two
conditions 1) that students who were arrested exercising their
legitimate right to protest be freed and 2) that calling them "coup
plotters" or "terrorists" for engaging in nonviolent protests to demand
their rights is unacceptable.
February 12 in Venezuela is a national youth day and students across the country organized nonviolent
mass demonstrations in response to the earlier repression
and were met with violence by regime officials working in coordination
with paramilitary groups known as "colectivos." Students were shot in the head and killed. This escalated the protests and as the violence
increased the demands expanded and began to focus on Maduro. These facts are conveniently ignored by Ms. Pearson in her article.
What happened in Mexico?
Students trashed City Hall in Iguala in 2013 after the slaying of a leftist social activist. Iguala is located 80 miles south of Mexico City in the state of Guerrero. The murdered activist's widow, Sofia Mendoza, a City Council member, blames Mayor Abarca for that killing. The Mayor and his wife, Maria de los Angeles Pineda, were believed to have ordered local police to intercept and
do away with the students who were
en route to Iguala and might
have disrupted a party and speech
by Ms. Pineda on September 26, 2014 and were attacked before reaching their destination: six were killed, 25 were wounded and 43 went missing and
have not been seen again.
More than 50 people have been
arrested in connection with the disappearances, the majority of them
police officers or members of the local drug gang Guerreros Unidos, all
of whom authorities say were working together. It now appears that the mayor's wife, Pineda was the
“principal operator” of Guerreros Unidos in Iguala.
The governor, Angel Aguirre, took a leave of absence because of the scandal,
which has also handed President Enrique Peña Nieto his worst crisis during his presidency. Several
top leaders of the left who had given Abarca their support have now distanced themselves from the tainted mayor.
The Mexican government is saying that those arrested have admitted to
killing the students and burning their remains. Family members are questioning the official version
as one parent stated: "We are not going to believe anything until the experts tell us: You know what? It is them,"
International Coverage
Searching Google
212 reports mention protesters killed in Venezuela versus
220 reports mentioning 43 students killed in Mexico. Unfortunately, the campaign by Maduro apologists to slander the student movement in Venezuela while restricting the access of independent international human rights organizations
to investigate what has taken place in Venezuela in stark contrast to the cooperation by the national Mexican government welcoming the
Inter-American Commission on Human Rights to investigate and
not expelling or
demonizing human rights organizations such as
Human Rights Watch.
From Military Dictators to Populists
Forty years ago
military dictatorships in Latin America
were murdering left wing students and in 2014 in Venezuela and Mexico populist left wing politicians are using police, para-militaries and gangs to murder left wing students who do not obey them. One constant
during these 40 years is that the dictatorship in Cuba
has had and continues
to have good relations with regimes that murder students.
This is Latin America in 2014.
Posts
